Car insurance is supposed to protect your finances—not create expensive surprises. Unfortunately, many North Carolina drivers make coverage decisions based only on the monthly premium. That can leave them paying far more after an accident, vehicle theft, insurance lapse, or other unexpected event.

Avoiding these common car insurance mistakes can help you control costs while keeping the protection you need.

1. Choosing Coverage Based Only on the Lowest Price

A low premium may look attractive, but the least expensive policy is not always the best value. It may come with lower liability limits, higher deductibles, fewer optional protections, or exclusions you did not expect.

When comparing quotes, make sure you are comparing equivalent coverage. Look at:

  • Liability limits
  • Comprehensive and collision deductibles
  • Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage
  • Rental reimbursement
  • Towing and roadside assistance
  • Medical payments coverage
  • Policy exclusions and limitations

Saving a few dollars each month may not be worthwhile if it leaves you responsible for thousands of dollars after a claim.

2. Carrying Only North Carolina’s Minimum Liability Limits

For policies issued or renewed on or after July 1, 2025, North Carolina requires minimum liability limits of:

  • $50,000 for bodily injury to one person
  • $100,000 for bodily injury to two or more people in one accident
  • $50,000 for property damage in one accident

These limits are commonly written as 50/100/50. North Carolina policies must also include uninsured and underinsured motorist protection. North Carolina Division of Motor Vehicles explains the state’s current requirements.

Meeting the legal minimum does not necessarily mean you have enough protection. A serious injury can generate substantial medical bills and lost income, while the price of many newer vehicles can quickly consume a property damage limit.

If a covered claim exceeds your policy limits, you could be personally responsible for the remaining amount. Drivers with income, savings, a home, or other assets should discuss whether higher liability limits—or a personal umbrella policy—would provide more appropriate protection.

3. Letting Your Insurance Lapse

Allowing a policy to expire, even briefly, can be an expensive mistake. North Carolina requires continuous liability insurance on vehicles with active state registration. Insurance companies must notify the N.C. Division of Motor Vehicles when coverage is canceled or lapses.

A lapse can lead to civil penalties, fees, registration problems, and possible revocation of the vehicle’s license plate. It may also make future insurance more expensive.

If you are changing insurance companies, make sure the new policy becomes effective before the old policy is canceled. If you are selling or storing a vehicle and plan to cancel its liability coverage, follow NCDMV requirements for surrendering the license plate first. NCDMV specifically warns drivers to purchase replacement coverage before canceling an existing policy.

Automatic payments and renewal reminders can also help prevent an accidental lapse.

4. Selecting a Deductible You Cannot Comfortably Pay

Increasing your comprehensive or collision deductible may lower your premium. However, the savings can backfire if you cannot afford the deductible when your vehicle is damaged.

For example, choosing a $1,000 collision deductible means you will generally be responsible for the first $1,000 of a covered repair. If paying that amount unexpectedly would create a financial emergency, a lower deductible may make more sense.

Choose a deductible that balances monthly affordability with the amount you could realistically pay after a loss.

5. Dropping Comprehensive or Collision Coverage Too Soon

Drivers sometimes remove physical damage coverage as soon as a vehicle is paid off. That can reduce the premium, but it also means the driver may receive no payment for damage to their own vehicle after an at-fault collision.

Collision coverage generally helps pay for damage caused by hitting another vehicle or object. Comprehensive coverage generally applies to non-collision losses such as theft, vandalism, fire, hail, flooding, falling objects, broken glass, and contact with an animal. The North Carolina Department of Insurance provides additional explanations of these coverages.

Before removing either coverage, consider:

  • Your vehicle’s current value
  • The premium and deductible
  • Whether you could afford to repair or replace the vehicle yourself
  • Whether losing the vehicle would affect your ability to work or meet family responsibilities

If the vehicle is financed or leased, your lender will typically require comprehensive and collision coverage.

6. Forgetting About Uninsured and Underinsured Drivers

Even when another driver causes an accident, that driver may not have insurance—or may not carry enough insurance to cover the full loss.

Uninsured motorist coverage can help when an at-fault driver has no applicable insurance. Underinsured motorist coverage can help with covered injuries when the other driver’s liability protection is insufficient. North Carolina requires these protections, but the amount of coverage still matters.

Do not assume the state-required limit will be adequate for every accident. Ask your agent to explain your limits, what losses are covered, and whether higher limits make sense.

7. Failing to List Household or Regular Drivers

A policy should accurately identify household members and other people who regularly drive the insured vehicles. Failing to disclose a newly licensed teenager, partner, roommate, or other regular driver can create rating problems and potential claim complications.

Tell your agent when:

  • A teenager receives a learner’s permit or driver’s license
  • Someone moves into or out of your household
  • A household member begins regularly using your vehicle
  • A driver’s license status changes
  • A vehicle’s primary driver changes

Accurate information helps ensure that the policy is written and priced correctly.

8. Not Updating How the Vehicle Is Used

Your premium and coverage may be affected by how, where, and how often you drive. Notify your agent if you begin working from home, change your commute, move, use the vehicle for business, or start driving for a delivery or rideshare platform.

Personal auto policies may limit or exclude certain business, delivery, and rideshare activities. Assuming that every use of your car is covered can result in an unpleasant surprise after an accident.

9. Skipping Rental Reimbursement or Roadside Assistance Without Considering the Consequences

Rental reimbursement and towing coverage are optional, but they may be valuable when an insured vehicle is disabled or undergoing covered repairs.

Without rental reimbursement, you may have to pay for alternative transportation yourself while your car is in the shop. Supply shortages and repair delays can make that expense larger than expected.

Review the daily and total limits before purchasing rental coverage. A low daily allowance may not cover the current cost of a suitable rental vehicle.

10. Assuming Personal Belongings Are Covered by Auto Insurance

Comprehensive coverage may cover damage to or theft of the vehicle, but it generally does not cover personal belongings stolen from inside it. Items such as laptops, phones, tools, luggage, and sports equipment may instead be covered—subject to limits and deductibles—by a homeowners or renters insurance policy.

Keeping a home inventory and reviewing your property coverage can help you understand how those belongings are protected.

11. Ignoring Available Discounts

Drivers may miss savings because their policy information is outdated or they never ask about discounts. Depending on the insurance company and your eligibility, savings may be available for:

  • Insuring multiple vehicles
  • Combining auto and home or renters insurance
  • Paying the premium in full
  • Using paperless billing or automatic payments
  • Having certain vehicle safety or anti-theft features
  • Maintaining favorable driving habits
  • Qualifying through an approved driver program

Discounts vary by insurer, and the cheapest policy after discounts is not automatically the policy with the best overall protection. An independent agent can help compare the complete value of each option.

12. Waiting Until Renewal to Review Your Policy

Your insurance needs can change throughout the year. Buying a vehicle, adding a driver, moving, changing jobs, getting married, or paying off a car can all affect your coverage.

Review your policy at least once a year and whenever you experience a major life change. Confirm that:

  • Every vehicle and regular driver is listed correctly
  • Your address and vehicle use are accurate
  • Liability limits reflect your current financial situation
  • Deductibles remain affordable
  • Optional coverages still meet your needs
  • Available discounts have been applied

Make Sure Your Coverage Works Before You Need It

The costliest car insurance mistakes are often discovered only after an accident. A proactive policy review can uncover coverage gaps, outdated information, and opportunities to save before they become expensive problems.

Fairway Insurance & Risk Management can help you compare options, understand your North Carolina auto insurance coverage, and balance price with meaningful protection. Contact Fairway Insurance today to request a personalized policy review.

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not modify or replace the terms of any insurance policy. Coverage, eligibility, limits, exclusions, and discounts vary by policy and insurance company. Please consult a licensed insurance professional regarding your specific needs.

Posted in blog